Decision not to charge Ariz. sheriff isn’t the end

Other cases pending against Joe Arpaio

Arpaio Enlarge photo

Arpaio

PHOENIX The federal abuse-of-power investigation into Americas self-proclaimed toughest sheriff may have been closed without criminal charges but Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaios legal troubles are far from over.

A civil case brought by a small group of Latinos who accuse Arpaios office of systematically racially profiling is awaiting a verdict from an Arizona-based federal judge.

The U.S. Department of Justice also has sued the sheriff for alleged constitutional violations, including racial profiling, retaliating against his critics, punishing Latino jail inmates with limited English skills for speaking Spanish and failing to adequately investigate a large number of sex-crimes cases. No trial date in that case has been set.

The Justice Department announced late Friday that it would not pursue criminal charges against the sheriff or his office, or against former Maricopa County top prosecutor Andrew Thomas and a top Thomas aide, Lisa Aubuchon, for abuse of power.

Thomas and Aubuchon were disbarred by the state Supreme Court earlier this year after an ethics panel decided they brought criminal charges against two county officials and a judge in December 2009 with the purpose of embarrassing them. The cases were investigated by Arpaios now-closed anti-public corruption squad.

Thomas was a longtime Arpaio ally.

Authorities were investigating Arpaio for his part in failed public corruption cases against officials who were at odds with him. The sheriff brought cases against a judge and two county officials in 2009, and Thomas prosecuted them.

Federal authorities also said Friday that they have decided not to prosecute matters tied to alleged misuse of county credit cards by sheriffs officials, alleged misspending of jail-enhancement funds and other matters.

The yearslong probe by the FBI and federal prosecutors into Arpaio, Thomas and their offices began during the tenure of President George W. Bush, although Arpaio, a fellow Republican, since has called it politically motivated.

If I did something wrong, there would be indictments floating all over the place, Arpaio said at a news conference called late Friday night. Im not going to get into all the details whether its political, a witchhunt or whatever you have. The bottom line is we were cleared, and we should stay with that and not get into all the politics involved.

Arpaio critics reacted with dismay to the decision not to seek criminal charges, saying they had hoped the Justice Department finally would act against what they call an out-of-control sheriffs office.

Its an understandable reaction, said Paul Charlton, a former U.S. attorney in Arizona who has worked for one of the county supervisors who was charged. I can see how, after so many years and so much misconduct by Joe Arpaio, you would have that feeling.

Tout JS Macro