In animal welfare, a phenomenon known as “black dog syndrome” has become widely accepted. This theory suggests black dogs are often overlooked for adoption in favor of dogs with a more interesting coat color and pattern. Similarly, black cats are reported to face similar challenges in finding forever homes. While initial studies appeared to support this notion, subsequent research has painted a more nuanced picture.
Contrary to popular belief, recent studies have challenged the validity of black dog syndrome, labeling it a myth. While early research indicated a longer wait time for black dogs before adoption, more comprehensive studies across various shelters have debunked this idea. Surprisingly, some findings even suggest that black dogs may be adopted more quickly than their lighter-coated counterparts. This discrepancy highlights the importance of data-driven decision-making and messaging within animal welfare organizations. In regards to black dogs, adoption trends need to be evaluated from a broader perspective.
Several theories attempt to explain the phenomenon of black dog syndrome. Some attribute it to deep-seated superstitions associating the color black with misfortune or evil, similar to the stigma surrounding black cats. Others point to practical factors, such as the challenges black dogs face in photographing well for online profiles, potentially impacting their visibility to prospective adopters. Nevertheless, while appearance strongly influences adoption decisions, studies indicate that it’s just one of many factors considered by those seeking to add a furry companion to their family. Personality, size, coat length and texture, behavior and history are all considered by adopters when deciding on a new pet.
La Plata County Humane Society currently has 12 black dogs awaiting adoption, suggesting ongoing relevance of this discussion. Despite the strides made in understanding adoption trends, there’s still work to be done in dispelling myths and ensuring that every shelter animal, regardless of coat color, finds a loving home. By raising awareness and continuing to embrace a more inclusive approach to adoption, we can help mitigate the effects of black dog syndrome and give each animal the chance they deserve.
Colleen Dunning is development manager at La Plata County Humane Society.
