Log In

Reset Password
News Education Local News Nation & World New Mexico

Can life survive in the Animas River?

Fish controls show promising results early on

As about 1 million gallons of toxic sludge makes its way from Gold King Mine down the Animas River, scientists, politicians and Durango residents are bracing for the environmental fallout.

At a public meeting Friday, the Environmental Protection Agency said initial testing indicates the water contains levels of cadmium, lead, aluminum, copper and arsenic too high for safe drinking water.

In an interview after the meeting, David Ostrander, program director for the EPA’s Preparedness, Assessment and Emergency Response, said the agency is closely monitoring wildlife.

Right now, fish are ecologically playing the role of a canary in the mine shaft, their survival serving as an indicator of the mine spillage’s greater impact on the environment.

Joe Lewandowski, spokesman for Colorado Department of Parks and Wildlife, said test fish seem to be withstanding the onslaught of heavy metals: Of the 108 fingerling rainbow trout that Parks and Wildlife submerged in cages along the Animas River on Thursday night, Lewandowski said one had died.

Though an encouraging sign, Lewandowski said the real question is how the fish fare after four or five days of protracted exposure to the metals surging through the water.

And it could take months to understand the full impacts, including what happened to insects, whether brown trout are reproducing and what effects metal-laden sediment will have on the riverbed, he said.

“It’s not something we can figure out instantly,” Lewandowski said.

Ostrander said the EPA is making arrangements to analyze whether the mine spillage has poisoned the invertebrate species living in the Animas – in some ways a more significant biological test of the environmental harm caused by the Gold King spillage and the ecosystem’s long-term fragility.

Though it may takes months before the environmental damage wrought by the Gold King spillage is understood, it’s not the first time Durango has seen Silverton’s mines spew contaminants downriver, causing regional environmental disasters.

In 1974, miners breached one of Silverton’s main tailing ponds, causing 100,000 tons of gray sludge to surge into the Animas River, washing away a part of the highway and prompting regulators to fine the mining company.

Then, in 1978, gold mining in Sunnyside Mine weakened Lake Emma’s rock basin until it finally collapsed. Allan Bird, a former miner turned historian, writes in his book about the Sunnyside mine: “Lake Emma broke through this spot and emptied thousands of gallons of water and over one million tons of mud into the mine. The crater above the surface was the length of three football fields and about 100 feet wide.”

At Friday’s public meeting, the larger consequences of the Gold King spillage on animals – and plants – living in the Animas River was at the forefront of many people’s questions.

“Humans are only one part of the ecosystem,” said Fort Lewis College environmental studies professor Janneli Miller.

She said the Gold King spill is a “tragedy for humans, but even more so for the innocent creatures who cannot remove themselves from this toxic waste.”

Ostrander assured her that the EPA is determined to save animal species.

“If you are seeing signs of animals that are dying, you let us know,” he said.


Aug 8, 2015
Action to deal with Animas River contamination slow moving
Aug 7, 2015
EPA’s slow response over Animas River mine spill raises ire of local, state politicians
Aug 7, 2015
Local businesses starting to feel the pinch from a soiled Animas River
Aug 7, 2015
EPA takes blame for Animas River contamination

Reader Comments